To moderate a panel discussion well, you do three jobs. You prepare the panelists. You keep the talk moving. And you bring the room in. Most panels get the first two roughly right and fail the third. The moderator reads long prepared questions, each panelist answers at length, and the audience gets five minutes and one roaming mic at the end.
This guide covers all three jobs. The core of it is a step-by-step walkthrough for running audience questions through an upvoted, moderated live Q&A, with the real settings named. Follow it and the room decides which questions matter, while you still decide what reaches the screen.
How to moderate a panel discussion: the three jobs
The moderator is not a fourth panelist. Your job is to make the panelists useful to the people in the seats. That work starts a week before the event.
Before the day
- Hold a short prep call. Agree on the one question the panel exists to answer. Ask each panelist for one view they hold that the others may not share. That is where the debate will come from.
- Cut the bios. Two sentences per person, read by you. Nobody came to hear a CV.
- Write five seed questions. You will use two or three. The rest are a safety net if the room is slow to start.
- Plan the audience blocks. Decide now when the room gets the floor, and tell the panelists.
Kristin Arnold, a professional meeting facilitator, gives the same advice in her Toastmaster magazine guide to moderating a panel. Research the topic, the panelists and the audience first. She also notes you can take audience questions as you go or set fixed times for them. We prefer fixed blocks with the question board open the whole time. People type while the thought is fresh, and you answer when the flow allows.
A sample run of show for a 45-minute panel
These timings are a plan to adapt, not a rule.
| Starts | Segment | Minutes |
|---|---|---|
| 0:00 | Hook, the question board goes up, two-line intros | 5 |
| 0:05 | Hot-take poll and the first reactions | 4 |
| 0:09 | Prepared questions | 14 |
| 0:23 | First audience block, top upvoted questions | 7 |
| 0:30 | Prepared questions, follow-ups | 5 |
| 0:35 | Second audience block | 8 |
| 0:43 | One closing sentence from each panelist | 2 |
Fifteen of the 45 minutes belong to the room. That is the point. The panel answers the audience, not just the moderator.
Why the roaming mic fails a panel
Running a mic around the room is slow. It also hands the floor to the most confident people, who often make a statement instead of asking a question. Junior staff will not challenge a keynote speaker with their name and face attached.
Seat time is already heavy at work. Harvard Business Review on meeting load reports that executives spend nearly 23 hours a week in meetings. And Gallup’s workplace research puts global employee engagement at 20% in 2025. A panel will not fix that number. But a panel that asks nothing of the room is one more hour of sitting still.
A typed, upvoted question board fixes the mic problems at once. Everyone can ask. The room ranks what it wants answered. And the moderator sees every question before choosing what to read.
Step by step: a moderated, upvoted live Q&A for your panel
Here is the full setup in RiLiFi’s live Q&A, in the order you meet the settings.
Step 1: Create the Q&A and pick a moderation mode
Create the Q&A inside the event’s folder. Then set Moderation to one of two modes:
- Auto-approve: questions go live the moment they are sent. Fast, and fine for a trusted internal team.
- Review first: you approve each question before anyone sees it. Use it for a public panel, a senior speaker or a touchy topic. Review first is on Creator and above. On Free, the Q&A runs on Auto-approve.
On either mode, turn on the profanity filter. It blocks common English swear words before they reach the room.
Step 2: Leave names off
Ask for a name is off by default, so questions are anonymous. Keep it that way for an internal panel. The best questions are often the ones people would never ask with their name attached. For a customer event where you want to follow up, turn it on. Names then show on questions, and the report lists who upvoted.
Step 3: Set what the audience sees
- Audience sees all questions: on. If it is off, people see only their own questions and cannot upvote.
- Sort phones by upvotes: on, so the most wanted questions sit at the top of every phone.
- Questions per person: two or three keeps the list readable. The range is 1 to 10, and deleted questions still count.
- Edit once: people can fix a typo once, and only before anyone upvotes it.
- Screen refresh: phones refresh every 5, 10, 15 or 30 seconds. A shorter gap lets the room watch questions climb.
Step 4: Decide who moderates
The owner of the Q&A, or whoever started the session, can moderate it. That holds even with View access. So if a colleague will run the queue while you sit on stage, share the folder with them through smart folders. They start the Q&A and moderate that session. Plan for one person on the queue, so two people do not approve the same item twice.
If you moderate alone from the stage, use Moderate from your phone. You run the queue from your hand, with no laptop on your knees.
Step 5: Open the board in the first minute
Put the PIN and QR code on a slide that stays up. People join at rilifi.com/join, with no app and no account. Then say the rules out loud, once:
- Questions are anonymous.
- Each question can be up to 200 characters.
- Upvote the ones you want answered.
The 200-character limit does real work. It turns a speech into a question.
Step 6: Screen, rank, then ask
Before each audience block, clear the queue. With Review first, approve the questions that belong. The rest never reach the screen. Then read the top upvoted question word for word and name the panelist who should take it. When three questions ask the same thing, say so and merge them out loud. The room sees you respect the rank.
Do not skip the top question because it is awkward. If the room voted it up, the room wants it. Hand it to the panelist best placed to answer and move on. Our guide on moderating questions before they appear walks through the Review first screens.
Step 7: Close the loop
Every Q&A session is archived in session history, with every question and its upvotes. Free plans see the report on screen. CSV export is on Creator and above. Send the top unanswered questions to the panelists after the event and post their short replies with the recap.
Add a hot-take poll before the first question
A panel warms up faster when the room commits first. Before the panelists speak, ask one tough question in a live poll.
- Poll: Will AI replace developers by 2030?
- Result: 60 percent Yes. 40 percent No.
That split is only an example. Use your real one. Then turn to the panel: most of the room thinks you are wrong, so tell them why. The debate starts on its own.
Keep it tight. Two options beat six, and each option can be up to 100 characters. Uncheck Ask for a name so nobody votes for the boss’s view. On a standalone poll, the live chart fills as votes arrive, so set a short timer, close voting, then show the results. Phones see the results only after voting closes.
If you want the bars hidden until you reveal them, build the panel as an interactive presentation and set the poll slide to Show results: When I reveal. A poll slide and a Q&A slide in one presentation share one PIN. Two standalone activities each have their own.
Hybrid and streamed panels
Remote viewers join the same session by PIN, QR code or link. Their questions and upvotes count the same as the front row’s. Share the host screen in the call so they can see their question climb. Read remote questions with the same weight. If you skip them, the people online become viewers, and viewers drift off.
For more on keeping an anonymous board civil in a large room, see our guide to moderating anonymous questions at an all-hands.
Panel moderator checklist
- Prep call done, one core question agreed, bios cut to two lines.
- Q&A created in the event folder, Moderation set, profanity filter on.
- Ask for a name off, unless you need follow-ups.
- Audience sees all questions and Sort phones by upvotes both on.
- One person on the queue, on a laptop or using Moderate from your phone.
- PIN and QR on a slide that stays up. A backup hotspot in your bag.
- Two audience blocks in the run of show, and the panelists know when.
- Top unanswered questions sent to panelists the same week.
RiLiFi’s free tier allows 100 participants per session, so a mid-size room is not cut off by a paywall. Bigger halls need a paid plan: 500 people on Creator, 1,000 on Pro and 5,000+ on Enterprise.
The mic can still exist for a follow-up. It is just not the intake. The board is the intake, and the moderator is the editor.
For your next panel: Set up a Live Q&A board for free.